Event details



Arnaud J Le Hors (IBM)
Arthur Ryman (IBM)
Arnaud J Le Hors (IBM), Arthur Ryman (IBM),, Gauthier Fanmuy (DS), Ian Green (IBM), Nick Crossley (IBM), Samuel Padgett (IBM), Steve Speicher (IBM)
Didier Simoneau (DS), Harish Krishnaswamy (Software AG), Jim Conallen (IBM)
  • Minutes of 13 November 2014 approved unanimously
  • Next TC call will be on 8 January 2015
  • NA

Original Chat transcript from room: oslc

Roll Call

[07:14] Arnaud J Le Hors (IBM): Arnaud J Le Hors (IBM) Arthur Ryman (IBM) Gauthier Fanmuy ian green Nick Crossley (IBM) Samuel Padgett (IBM) Steve Speicher (IBM)

Approval of Minutes of 13 November 2014

[07:15] Arthur Ryman (IBM): No objections, approved.

Next Call

[07:16] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Next call Jan. 8, 2015

Authoring tools

[07:18] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: previous process embedded shapes and vocabs in HTML, then manually create RDF version

[07:19] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: proposed process is to make RDF documents the source and generate HTML using ReSpec

[07:19] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: would like to have more use to validate the approach

[07:20] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: Sam has used this approach

[07:24] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arthur: will shape documents be published like vocabs?

[07:24] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: Yes. We will use as the hostname for URIs and redirect to OASIS

[07:25] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Guathier: What is a shape?

[07:26] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arthur: See

[07:27] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: See also new W3C workgroup:


[07:27] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: Steve is working on a proposal

[07:28] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: See wiki:

[07:29] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: need co-existence with V2, also align with Linked Data Platform

[07:31] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: exploring use of HTTP headers

[07:32] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: collecting use cases, e.g. what shapes can I POST to a container?

[07:32] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: one solution is to add a property to the container, e.g. oslc:createShape

[07:34] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: added User Story to W3C RDF Data Shapes WG, see

[07:36] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: everyone should review the proposal and send comments to the mailing list

Compatibility with V2

[07:38] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: Steve and Sam created a draft

[07:38] Arthur Ryman (IBM): See

[07:40] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: used CM as the model

[07:40] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: query syntax may be superceded by a future LDP filter language

[07:41] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: RDF/XML may be demoted to "unspecified", Turtle and JSON-LD are MUST

[07:42] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: for OSLC we may need RDF/XML for backward compatibility

[07:43] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Ian: are there guidelines for how to evolve to V3?

[07:43] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: Yes, section 5 onwards

[07:46] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: everyone should review the proposal and send comments to mailing list

Core V3 Draft

[07:47] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: have overview of V3

[07:48] Arthur Ryman (IBM): See

[07:48] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: everyone should review the proposal and send comments to mailing list

[07:49] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: we should also assign actions to individuals, starting next year


[07:50] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Sam: spec is solidifying, added vocab terms to core

[07:51] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Sam: LDP container manages non-RDF attachments, uses Link Headers

[07:52] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Sam: see example section in

[07:54] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: simplicity is a goal

[07:55] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Sam: pls give feedback on structure of spec, i.e. numbering of sections for compliance

[07:55] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: I like it, it is useful to identify requirements

[07:56] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Sam: requirements have URIs

Proposal to add oslc:archived

[07:57] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: are we waiting for feedback from Bill?

[07:58] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Steve: No, it is added to spec and will be included in the review of the draft

[07:58] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Arnaud: let's discuss at next meeting

Round Robin Updates

[08:00] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Nick: No action on my item due to absence

[08:00] Arnaud J Le Hors (IBM): Configuration context header

[08:00] Arthur Ryman (IBM): Nick: specs will be firmed up in coming weeks, will draft RFC for IETF on link headers

Meeting ends

Meetings/Telecon2014.12.11 (last edited 2015-01-08 14:59:52 by alehors)